But why? Lidge is 0-2 with a 10.80 ERA and four saves in seven opportunities in nine appearances since Aug. 6.
"Because he's good," Utley said. "He's got good stuff. He's got dominant stuff. The numbers can lie a little bit sometimes, but opposing teams do not like facing him."
Lidge blew a save in a 6-4 loss to the Pirates on Tuesday, his fourth consecutive day on the mound. Lidge said afterward that historically he does not pitch well on his fourth consecutive day. He entered that game 2-1 with a 5.40 ERA in six appearances in that situation, although he had been scoreless in his previous four, including twice in May.
The Phillies had another save opportunity in Wednesday's game against the Pirates, but Lidge was given the day off. Ryan Madson pitched the ninth with a 1-0 lead, but allowed a solo homer to Brandon Moss to tie the game. The Phillies went on to win, 4-1, in 10 innings.
Phillies pitching coach Rich Dubee said he asked Lidge before Tuesday's game how he felt and Lidge said he was ready to go. When he called the bullpen in the ninth, Lidge reiterated he felt good. Lidge said after the game he would pitch 10 consecutive days if asked, but the Phillies might have to rethink how they use him. Lidge has a 9.87 ERA when he pitches on no rest this season. He has a 5.83 ERA when he pitches on one day of rest or more.
A 5.83 ERA still is troubling, but it is more than a four-run improvement.
"We will from now on, yeah," Dubee said, asked if he must guard against pitching Lidge four consecutive days. "If he doesn't think the fourth day is good, maybe we'll just go two. I don't know. We'll see how it plays out."
Asked if he sees a situation where Lidge is not the closer entering the playoffs, Dubee said, "Right now, no. We'll see how it plays out."
Right-hander Brett Myers was scheduled to pitch two innings Wednesday night in Double A Reading. He is the best alternative to replace Lidge because has closed before. But he hasn't closed since 2007 and he is returning from surgery on his right hip. To get Manuel to move from Lidge to Myers, it stands to reason Lidge would have to continue his current struggles and Myers would have to be dominant. Lidge still has two years remaining on his contract, so the Phillies are thinking long-term, too.
So Lidge remains entrenched for the immediate future, while his counterparts in the bullpen try to be as supportive as possible. Everybody inside the Phillies insist Lidge is healthy -- he spent time on the disabled list earlier this season with a sprained right knee -- and that his stuff is good. They said his mechanics were out of whack at one point, but that no longer seems to be a focus of his problems.
"If you have advice give it, but don't ostracize him," right-hander Chad Durbin said. "It's like family. You're going to let him figure some things out on his own. He knows how to right the ship. If we see something we'll say something to him, but we know everybody is coming at him. We'll listen to him if he has stuff he has to get off his chest."
Confidence would seem to be a major issue at this point, although Lidge has said he has confidence on the mound. But Lidge looked shell-shocked after Tuesday's loss.
"Baseball can be crude at times," Durbin said. "And you can also forget about a bad season in a good run in September and October. The velocity is there. The breaking ball is there. He needs the confidence. Hitters are like sharks. A little bit of blood. Serious. As soon as you give them something like that, they'll smell it and go after you."
Lidge's goal is to stop the bleeding before it's too late.